Best Milk for Instant Pudding: Dairy vs Plant-Based (Keto & Gluten-Friendly)

Best milk for instant pudding — did you know milk or a plant-based milk alternative can be the key to a delicious, guilt-free decadent dessert?

Today we’re discussing what milk and milk alternatives work best with keto and gluten-friendly puddings. That is why we are looking at Plant-Based Milk. If you’ve ever wondered which carton in your fridge is the best milk for instant pudding when you want a creamy, silky set, this guide has you covered.

While we encourage you to release your inner creativity in the kitchen and try out endless tempting recipe combinations, some dairy and non-dairy alternatives just work better together.

We’ve got the lowdown on what works best if you want to enjoy a sugar-free, diabetic-friendly but tasty, guilt-free dessert. View our recipes here.

Table of Contents

Dairy or Non-Dairy milk? What milk works best in keto & decadent puddings?

Take almond milk, for example, currently the leading milk alternative in the US with oat milk being a close second choice.

Almond milk is enjoyed for its rich and nutty flavor, not to mention its low fat and lower calories. It ticks plenty of “dietary” benefit boxes. But it can have a bitter, acidic edge that’s not to everyone’s palate. Poured straight into hot coffee, it tends to curdle—and nobody wants that to happen when they’re showcasing a new dessert for friends and family.

Is non-dairy milk a popular trend in the preparation of diabetic-friendly desserts?

Indeed, the demand for alternative dairy has never been higher. It’s a trend that doesn’t look like it’s going away any time soon.

According to Morning Consult, 67% of U.S. adults have now tried a non-dairy milk, with many citing they enjoy the taste as well as the health and sustainability benefits.

If you want to give your family a sugar-free, allergen-free, keto, vegan, non-GMO verified, kosher, halal & natural pudding, you should consider a range that is based on the founding principles of being plant-based and lactose-free. That way, you can be sure that you are giving your family a delicious dessert that’s entirely suitable for all sufferers of allergies in your household.

We recommend that you go for something compatible with non-dairy recipes using soy, oat milk, flax milk & vanilla almond milk. Meaning that delicious healthy desserts can be a reality for everyone. Alternative sources of milk—the plant-based market is huge.

Alternative milk sources, particularly soy, have been around for years now, and their popularity has exploded of late.

According to Everyday Health, the plant-milk market was worth $12 billion back in 2019 and that growth rate is expected to compound annually by 11% between 2020 and 2026. You’re certainly not alone if you’ve already switched to plant-based milk.

How do certain dairy and non-dairy products affect the taste, texture & color of your desserts?

Why is it, for example, that cream tastes just so… creamy? You guessed it… three little letters that together spell something super tasty—FAT!

It’s the fat content in your favorite milk (dairy & plant-based) that gives it that delicious creamy flavor. That’s why choosing the right milk or milk alternative is always best done by looking at the fat content and sugar in your milk. We recommend at least 2.5% fat content for the most delicious and smooth dessert.

Do all plant-based milks deliver the same nutritional benefits?

While plant-based milk sources have plenty of nutritional benefits, they’re not all created equal.

As with any food or drink product, it is important to check the nutritional label for potential additives such as sugar, salt and oil, as well as added water content that can affect the ability of the liquid to blend effectively with your chosen Instant Pudding base.

Only products that contain the best quality allergen-free ingredients can claim that they are Allergen Free. Look out for hidden artificial ingredients, preservatives or colors in what you think is a healthy dessert and also be careful not to put any unwanted ingredients back “in” with your final choice of liquid mixer.

Should I avoid sweetened milk in my desserts?

Choosing the best liquid source affects the finished taste and texture and is also an essential consideration if you want to hit those net daily carbs to remain in ketosis.

As a general rule of thumb, all sweetened milk or alternative milk is best avoided as it’s higher in carbs and sugar.

Simply Desserts Instant Puddings have been designed to blend effortlessly with a range of liquid bases so that you can manage your dietary and allergy requirements. However, some milk sources just go better together with our tasty puds.

To ensure that you get the best possible flavor, texture and color combinations from your desserts, we’ve worked hard with a dedicated team of recipe influencers—blending and blitzing lots of Simply Desserts combinations to discover what works best.

It’s time to shake up your milk and your dessert game with keto puddings that are packed with a creamy taste and smooth, silky texture. Sweeteners can make instant pudding overly loose; stick to unsweetened cartons for a clean set and better flavor control.

What milk should I choose to make the best dessert?

We recommend adding 2 cups of 2% milk or 1¼ cup of sugar-free or keto-milk for best results. If you’re optimizing for the best milk for instant pudding, fat content and sweetness level are the two biggest levers.

Our favorites for mixing are:

• 1¼ cups of Oat Milk
• 1¼ cups of Soymilk
• 1¼ cups of Flax Milk
• 1¼ cups of Macadamia Milk

For instant pudding made extra rich, whole milk often delivers the creamiest texture and a glossy finish that holds up well in layered desserts. If you prefer plant-based, soy milk is a reliable swap for instant pudding with good body and a stable set.

When whisking instant pudding with soy milk, choose unsweetened varieties to control sugar and keep flavors clean. A brief rest in the fridge before serving enhances mouthfeel without dulling the vanilla or chocolate notes.

Milk Mixing Guide — Best Milk for Instant Pudding

For best results, start with these quick picks from our
Milk Mixing Guide:

• Milk — 2% or whole milk
• Oat Milk — Original or Unsweetened
• Coconut Milk — Original or Unsweetened
• Almond Milk — Original and Unsweetened (aim for ~3g fat)

Pro Mixing Guide

Learn the ideal milk-to-pudding ratios, mixing techniques, and serving tips to achieve the perfect silky-smooth texture every time you whip up Simply Desserts instant pudding. This is our short route to the best milk for instant pudding results at home.

• Plant-Based Milk — Discover how almond, oat, coconut, and other non-dairy milks interact with our sugar-free pudding mix, plus pro tips on which brands deliver the creamiest mouthfeel without compromising flavor.
• Whole Milk — Unlock the richness of whole milk with precise measurements and blending methods that enhance creaminess and depth of taste in every spoonful of instant pudding.
• Lactose-Free Milk — Customize your pudding experience with dairy-free options; learn which milks produce the smoothest consistency and how slight tweaks in mixing yield perfectly silky results.

Tip: Start cold, whisk thoroughly for 2 minutes, then chill for 10–15 minutes for the best set.

Expert Tips & Troubleshooting

If your pudding sets too softly, increase fat slightly (e.g., switch from almond to oat or 2% to whole milk) and extend chill time by 5–10 minutes; these two tweaks often yield the best milk for instant pudding results without changing flavor.

Brand formulas vary—some barista milks include stabilizers that thicken faster. Test a half-batch first to see which carton in your fridge delivers the best milk for instant pudding texture before serving guests.

Whisking matters: add the mix to cold milk in a steady rain and whisk for the full 2 minutes. Proper hydration of starches and proteins is a big reason you’ll get the best milk for instant pudding consistency every time. Use chilled bowls when making instant pudding, especially with soy milk, for a faster set and smoother finish.

Flavor Pairings & Ratios

For chocolate and butterscotch, oat milk brings gentle sweetness that flatters cocoa while whole milk deepens richness; both options give instant pudding a luscious, spoon-coating texture.

Vanilla and banana shine with oat milk (Original or Barista). If you prefer a custard-like profile, whole milk adds body, while soy milk keeps flavors clean and classic for weeknight instant pudding.

For fruity mixes like strawberry, start with cold oat milk at the printed ratio, then whisk for the full 2 minutes. This simple tweak helps your instant pudding set quickly and hold its shape for piping or layering.

Check out the best milk source at a glance!

We wanted to make life easier for you all, so we’ve put together this good mixer guide. Now you can quickly see at a glance whether Oat Milk Original works best with Strawberry Pudding or Butterscotch Pudding—for instant pudding flavor pairings that deliver every time.

We tried and tested the most popular liquid bases and assessed their impact on the color, taste and texture of these popular Instant Puddings.

It’s never been easier to create a dessert that meets your taste and specific allergen requirements.

Simply choose the liquid base best for you, then go ahead and enjoy an allergen-free, guilt-free, but never taste-free dessert every darn day!

Shop Delicious Instant Puddings by Simply Desserts